John 12:1-8

 In John 12:1-8, Mary’s act of pouring expensive perfume on Jesus’ feet shows us exactly what costly discipleship looks like: extravagant, misunderstood by others, yet beautiful to Christ. This moment isn’t just about perfume—it’s Mary recognizing that following Jesus involves a willingness to sacrifice something valuable, even when the people around her can’t understand. Judas calls it wasteful, but Jesus sees devotion. That tension is still alive today because true discipleship often challenges cultural norms or practical logic (Luke 9:23-25). Like Mary, when we embrace Jesus, we embrace a journey toward the cross, accepting the risks and ridicule that come with radical commitment.

But here's the thing: embracing the cross isn't about enduring suffering for suffering’s sake—it’s about trusting that on the other side is resurrection, transformation, and new life. Paul captures this beautifully when he writes in Galatians 2:20, “I have been crucified with Christ and I no longer live, but Christ lives in me.” Mary's costly offering points directly to this reality: we lose something precious (comfort, security, worldly approval) to gain something even greater (purpose, hope, a life truly alive in Christ). Her act of devotion foreshadows the incredible truth that death isn’t the end—it’s the pathway to something deeply good and lasting.

Today, our challenge is to consider what our own “perfume” might be—what valuable thing we might hesitate to pour out for Jesus because it seems too costly or risky. True discipleship involves moments where our faith moves from comfortable agreement to courageous action, just like Mary's. It’s not about striving to earn approval, but about realizing that when we pour out our lives in love and trust, we’re actually stepping into the abundant life Jesus promises (John 10:10). This is discipleship at its most personal and powerful—embracing the cost, yes, but also discovering that what we receive in return is infinitely richer.

Background of John

The Gospel of John derives its name from its traditionally attributed author, John the Apostle, one of Jesus’ twelve disciples. Unlike the Synoptic Gospels (Matthew, Mark, and Luke), John’s account stands out for its unique theological depth, emphasizing Jesus’ divine nature. Early church tradition associates this Gospel with Ephesus, where John is believed to have ministered in the latter part of the first century (Carson). The Greek title Kata Ioannen (“According to John”) appears in early manuscripts, affirming its longstanding attribution to the disciple.

Though the Gospel itself does not explicitly name its author, early church figures such as Irenaeus and Clement of Alexandria affirm that John, the son of Zebedee, penned it (Carson). Internal evidence supports this claim, particularly in its references to the “disciple whom Jesus loved” (John 21:20-24), traditionally identified as John. Additionally, the Gospel reflects an intimate knowledge of Jewish customs, geography, and firsthand encounters with Jesus, suggesting authorship by someone close to Him. While some modern scholars debate Johannine authorship, the early church's consistent testimony remains a compelling argument for John’s authorship (Kostenberger).

Most scholars date the Gospel of John between AD 85 and 95, making it the last of the four Gospels to be written (Kostenberger). By this time, Christianity had expanded beyond its Jewish roots, facing increasing opposition from both Jewish religious leaders and Roman authorities. The destruction of the Jerusalem Temple in AD 70 also reshaped Jewish-Christian relations, making John’s emphasis on Jesus as the fulfillment of Jewish hopes particularly significant. Tradition places the writing of the Gospel in Ephesus, a major center of early Christianity where John is believed to have lived and ministered in his later years (Keener).

John’s Gospel follows a clear structure:
Prologue (1:1-18) – Establishes Jesus as the divine Word who became flesh.
The Book of Signs (1:19–12:50) – Narrates Jesus’ public ministry, featuring seven key miracles.
The Book of Glory (13:1–20:31) – Focuses on Jesus’ final teachings, His death, and resurrection.
Epilogue (21:1-25) – Concludes with Jesus’ post-resurrection appearances and final words to His disciples.
Unlike the Synoptics, which focus on parables and short sayings, John’s Gospel includes extended discourses, particularly Jesus’ farewell discourse in John 13-17, which provides theological insight into His mission and relationship with the Father.

John’s Gospel holds a unique place in the New Testament. While the Synoptics emphasize Jesus’ teachings and actions, John focuses on His identity and mission. The Gospel has been instrumental in shaping Christian theology, particularly in understanding the Trinity, Christ’s divinity, and the role of faith. Its poetic style, symbolic imagery, and theological depth make it a cornerstone of Christian thought. For believers, John offers not just historical testimony but an invitation to experience Christ personally. Its famous declaration—“I am the way and the truth and the life” (John 14:6)—continues to be a central proclamation of the Christian faith.

Connecting Luke 13:1-9 to The Book of Luke

John 12:1-8 serves as a bridge between Jesus’ public ministry (John 1-11) and His final days leading to the crucifixion (John 13-21).

The Climax of Jesus’ Miracles – The raising of Lazarus in John 11 was the final and most dramatic of Jesus’ miracles, proving His authority over death. This miracle not only foreshadows His resurrection but also sets in motion the events leading to His arrest and crucifixion.

Foreshadowing the Passion Narrative – John 12 begins the transition toward Jesus’ suffering. While Mary’s anointing points to His burial, the following events—the triumphal entry (John 12:12-19), Jesus predicting His death (John 12:23-36), and the increasing hostility from Jewish leaders (John 12:37-50)—further solidify the inevitability of the cross (Kostenberger).

The Contrast Between Devotion and Betrayal – The opposition between Mary and Judas in John 12:1-8 prefigures the coming betrayal in John 13, where Judas fully reveals his disloyalty by agreeing to hand Jesus over to His enemies. This contrast between genuine faith and self-serving rejection is a key theme in John’s Gospel (Keener).

Theological Significance 
John 12:1-8 highlights what true discipleship looks like—selfless devotion to Christ, recognizing His worth above all else. Mary’s act of worship mirrors John’s larger call to believe in Jesus fully. The Gospel repeatedly contrasts those who respond to Jesus in faith (like Mary, Lazarus, and the blind man in John 9) with those who reject or betray Him (like Judas, the Pharisees, and the crowds who later turn against Him). Additionally, Jesus' words in John 12:8, “You will always have the poor among you, but you will not always have me,” are not dismissing concern for the poor but emphasizing the urgency of His impending sacrifice. Jesus is about to fulfill the ultimate act of love—laying down His life for humanity.

Conclusion John 12:1-8 is a deeply symbolic passage that encapsulates the heart of John’s Gospel—recognizing Jesus as the Messiah, responding in faith, and preparing for His sacrificial death. As the narrative shifts toward the Passion, this scene serves as a powerful reminder that true discipleship is marked by extravagant love, bold faith, and unwavering devotion to Christ.

Overview of John 12:1-8 from a Wesleyan/Methodist Theological Perspective

John 12:1-8 offers a deeply symbolic moment in Jesus’ journey toward the cross, a passage rich with themes of grace, sacrificial love, and true discipleship—elements that resonate profoundly within Wesleyan/Methodist theology. In this passage, Mary of Bethany anoints Jesus' feet with expensive perfume, an act of extravagant devotion that draws the criticism of Judas Iscariot. Jesus defends her, revealing that her actions foreshadow His burial and emphasizing the significance of recognizing His presence while there is still time.

From a Wesleyan perspective, this passage speaks to the transformative power of grace and the call to holiness. John Wesley emphasized that salvation is not merely about personal redemption but about responding to God’s grace through love and service. Mary’s anointing is an example of prevenient grace at work—her devotion to Jesus is not random; it is the result of a heart transformed by the presence of Christ. In Wesleyan theology, prevenient grace enables individuals to recognize and respond to God’s movement in their lives, just as Mary recognizes Jesus’ worth in a way that Judas and others do not (Maddox).

Mary’s act of devotion also reflects the Wesleyan commitment to holiness of heart and life. Holiness, in the Methodist tradition, is not just about personal piety but about a life marked by love for God and neighbor. Her willingness to offer something costly—both in terms of financial value and social expectation—demonstrates the self-giving love that Wesley saw as the essence of Christian perfection (Outler). Unlike Judas, whose concern is self-serving, Mary exemplifies the kind of love that is central to Wesleyan discipleship: one that is sacrificial, responsive to grace, and centered on Christ.

The contrast between Mary and Judas also highlights another key Wesleyan theme: the responsible use of resources in light of God’s kingdom. Methodists have long emphasized social holiness—the belief that faith is not just personal but must be lived out in service to others. Judas’ protest, suggesting that the perfume should have been sold to benefit the poor, raises an important ethical question: how do we balance acts of worship with the call to serve others? Wesley himself was deeply committed to social justice, advocating for the care of the poor, yet he also insisted that true holiness begins with a heart wholly devoted to God (Runyon). Jesus’ response does not diminish the importance of caring for the poor, but it underscores the urgency of recognizing and responding to His presence. In Methodist thought, this moment is not an either/or dilemma—it is a call to a both/and faith, where worship fuels service, and devotion to Christ leads to love in action.

Furthermore, the passage reflects the Wesleyan understanding of justifying and sanctifying grace. Mary’s act symbolizes a heart fully surrendered to Christ, an image of justifying grace, where one moves from simply knowing about Jesus to experiencing the depth of His love. At the same time, her willingness to give so freely mirrors sanctifying grace, the ongoing process of being made holy through a life of devotion and service (Collins). In contrast, Judas embodies resistance to grace. Though he is physically near Jesus, his heart remains unchanged. This distinction serves as a Wesleyan reminder that discipleship is not about proximity to Christ but about a life transformed by His grace.

John 12:1-8, through a Wesleyan/Methodist lens, is ultimately a call to recognize Christ’s presence, respond to His grace with extravagant love, and live out our faith through acts of devotion and service. Mary’s example challenges believers to embrace a discipleship that is deeply personal yet outwardly expressed, reminding us that true worship and social holiness are inseparable. This passage invites us to consider how we are responding to Christ’s presence today—whether with the self-giving love of Mary or the self-centeredness of Judas. 

Bible Study Handout
All Bible Studies

Works Cited